Comments on:High Achievers: What Price Are They Paying?A Harvard University admissions interviewer describes how kids are being "packaged for success." Many are entirely focused on being accepted by an impressive college, while those students with a genuine love of learning seem to be disappearing.
May 27, 2009 8:07 PM Thank you but whose fault is it?
I am so glad to read such a view but unfortunately the author failed to recognize that parents are simply doing what the colleges are pushing them to do.
If Harvard is truly interested in the type of kids who grow up without being 'packaged', all Harvard needs to do is to admit 30% of students whose GPA and SAT do not count at all. Tell them submit their applications without GPA, without SAT and without AP class. All they need to do is to show how 'naturally they have grown up'.
64 people found this comment helpful
February 19, 2009 5:56 PM High Achievers
I have two high schoolers; they are both very different. One is a boy and one is a girl, both have "above average" I.Q's - not that means much. I placed my oldest (my son) in the IB program, because he "fit" the requirements - now 6 years later looking back I have caused him tremendous stress. He is a very social and athletic person;therefore, he is internally conflicted with maintaining the balance between grades, sports and a social life. He is meeting the requirements, but that is all. As a Sr. he is absolutely miserable. My daughter is a freshman in high school and an overachiever, she always has been. I have tried to relieve the stress at home by explaining that all I expect is the best she can do, but to her the best is excelling at everything, sports, social life and grades. She wants acceptance (as do most teen girls) from peers, teachers and of course her family. She is now at a breaking point. Society is pushing children to grow-up faster than they are ready to both mentally and physically. No wonder they are self-mutilating, binging and purging, or plain starving themselves - it is the only control they have over their lives -. Worst of all they are actually killing themselves - not crying for attention with attempted suicide -following through. We tell them the grades, the jobs, the schools they must attend - they can't let us down - we know it all.
Not only have I experienced this with my own childern I am also an educator. I have taught 4th, 6th, and College Prepartory Reading. I have heard more than one time, "my mom is going to kill me, because I did not get an 'A'; please give me extra-credit." Why are we pushing our youth to bear the stresses that many adults cannot handle? The bigger question is; why do we then wonder: Why are our teens killing themselves, killing others, and withrawling into a shell that can never be broken? Think about that the next time you ask your kindergartner, "Why did you make a 'B'?"
162 people found this comment helpful
|